Cooking With A Sandwich Press Thinking Outside The Box

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure statement.

Cooking In A Sandwich Press

Ideas When Cooking With A Sandwich Press

Cooking with a sandwich press is great, this is a kitchen tool that makes cooking so much easier. The thing about the sandwich press is that it’s all about your imagination, there are endless possibilities.

You can use a sandwich press for so much more than just sandwiches quesadillas, and paninis. I’m a big fan of cooking with a sandwich press and using it to make all sorts of dishes, that you would usually not think about.

Thinking outside the box when using my sandwich press I find is the best way to use it. There are some easy sandwich press recipes that I will share with you.

There are a lot of other people out there who love the convenience of this kitchen tool. The best part, is you don’t need a stove, oven, or even pots and pans.

In this post, I’m going to give you some great sandwich press ideas for cooking delicious quick, and easy meals. Your old-school kitchen appliance could become the newest cooking tool in your arsenal with some creativity and imagination.

Sure using your sandwich press to create and cook the ultimate toasted sandwich or panini is still great, let’s face it they taste so good. No one can deny the appeal of a crispy delicious toasted sandwich!

Delicious Toasted Sandwich
Delicious Toasted Sandwich

What Does A Sandwich Press Do?

Busy people lead busy lives and cooking may be too time-consuming and difficult to get everything just right. A sandwich press is an appliance that cooks not just toasted sandwiches quickly and efficiently, but just about anything you can think of.

Generally speaking, because the cooking process takes place in an environment with direct heat coming from the top and the bottom, The sandwich press will cook your food more evenly and thoroughly than other cookery methods.

The question I am often asked is “What can I cook on a sandwich press?” Think outside the box when cooking with a sandwich press.

You could cook anything from the most crispy bacon you’ve ever had to the juiciest burger patty that would put any professional chef to shame! The list of foods goes on and on!

Taking full advantage of your sandwich press, these kitchen tools make it so easy to cook your favorite foods faster than ever before.

They’re even more convenient than using an oven because the cooking time is less and they don’t use as much power!

Start thinking outside the box when it comes to cooking with a sandwich press. I’ll make it easy for you by sharing some great ideas that you can start cooking right now, today!

What To Cook In A Sandwich Press?

The short answer is just about anything. I’m sharing some of the dishes that I regularly cook in a sandwich press with some outstanding results that you wouldn’t believe were possible!

All you need to do is think outside the box when it comes to cooking with a sandwich press. It is that easy, not rocket science, if I can cook these foods in a sandwich press with awesome results so can you!

10 Reasons To Start Cooking With A Sandwich Press 1-5

#1 Bacon

Cooking Bacon In A Sandwich Press

You’re thinking can you cook bacon in a sandwich press? Cooking bacon in a sandwich press is easy! And it tastes awesome, I don’t know what it is about bacon, but it’s just so addictive.

You can cook bacon for breakfast in under five minutes with a sandwich press. I have to say this is my favorite way to cook bacon, it takes less time than toast!

I love the crispy texture that you get from cooking bacon in a sandwich press. It’s so easy too; all you really need are some paper towels for draining off any excess grease.

#2 Omelets

Cooking An Omelet In A Sandwich Press

It’s a foolproof plan, you can’t have bacon without eggs, and you can’t have eggs without breaking them. I can make a damn good omelet in a pan, however, a sandwich press omelet is next level! They are so easy to cook and look impressive too!

You can add any ingredients you want cheese, tomatoes, potatoes, and of course bacon. This dish cooked in a sandwich press will pack some punch without being overly complex or time-consuming! This is one of the great sandwich press breakfast recipes.

#3 Chicken Thighs

Cooking Chicken Thighs In A Sandwich Press

Cooking chicken thighs in a sandwich press couldn’t be easier, direct heat from the top and the bottom they cook evenly and fast too!

Put it in a toasted club sandwich with some avocado, lettuce, mayo, and your favorite cheese and you’ve got something magical for your taste buds!

I’ve always been a huge toasted club sandwich fan, everything is contained in a neat little package. See, if you take your meat patty out of the equation – most sandwiches won’t accommodate boneless skinless thigh fillets quite so well.

But not anymore! The invention of the sandwich press has made cooking chicken thighs more convenient than ever before!

The sandwich press cooks chicken thighs (and breast) absolutely perfect every time, you really need to try it. Here is an outstanding marinade for chicken thighs.

#4 Pizza

Cooking Pizza In A Sandwich Press

In this day and age, there are so many innovative ways to use a sandwich press. One of my favorites is using a sandwich press to cook pizza, truly an ingenious invention!

I love how quickly they cook in the press; the base crisps up nicely and you can add just about anything to the topping. With just a few ingredients and minimal effort, you can enjoy a hot and cheesy slice of pizza in no time at all.

You can’t go wrong using a sandwich press, add a little rice bran oil before placing the pizza base into the sandwich press.

You could even try cooking calzone in your sandwich press. Just don’t overload the filing. Cooking with a sandwich press when it comes to pizzas is simple, fast, and healthy! Your sandwich press pizza creation will make an awesome Pinterest pin too!

How To Cook Pizza In A Sandwich Press

#5 Lamb Cutlets

Grilled Lamb Cutlets Persian Saffron

Some people think cooking lamb cutlets is complicated and messy, well it’s not. Cooking them in a sandwich press is a game-changer, simple, controlled cooking.

There are so many sandwich press meals, lamb cutlets are a delicious one! Looking for ideas for dinner, try this marinade on your lamb cutlets.


  • Heat your sandwich press lightly brush the press with a little olive oil, and place in the lamb cutlets, you should be able to fit four at a time. and close it up.

Should take about 4 – 5 minutes, no need to turn them, take them out and rest them, you’ll have perfectly medium lamb cutlets, now that’s simple as!

Best Home Sandwich Press

Blue Diamond Cookware Sizzle Griddle/Sandwich Press

This Sandwich Press/Sizzle Griddle is perfect for any kitchen. This griddle offers a variety of options to satisfy all your cooking needs
It is awesome for cooking just about anything you can think of. You don’t need to be a kitchen pro to use this, when cooking with a sandwich press it is so easy!

Standout Features

  • Quicker and more economical than an oven, simple and easy to use.
  • This Sandwich Press/Sizzle Griddle will quickly become your favorite kitchen appliance.
  • These plates are diamond-infused which means they heat up faster and more evenly.
  • The cooking surface on both sides gives even heat across both plates which gives you the most beautiful sear possible on whatever you’re cooking.

10 Reasons To Start Cooking With A Sandwich Press 6-10

#6 Fresh Fish Fillets

Cooking Fish In A Sandwich Press

Things to do with a sandwich press are infinite. When your cooking with a sandwich press nothing is off-limits, like I said “think outside the box”.

Cooking fish in a sandwich press if you have skin on fillets, season the skin, let sit for a couple of minutes and place it skin side down onto the sandwich press.


  • Add a little butter and season the flesh side with Himalayan pink salt and freshly ground black pepper.

sprinkle over some fresh herbs like thyme or rosemary and close the lid, cook for two-three minutes. I know what you’re thinking, how can a sandwich press be used to cook fish?

Well, you can… and you can cook them perfectly. Most people indeed use their sandwich presses for the sole purpose of making toasted sandwiches.

#7 Burger Patties

Cooking Burger Patties In A Sandwich Press

Looking for other things to make in a sandwich press? When I first started cooking with a sandwich press I tried homemade burger patties.

I was skeptical about whether or not it would be worth it. Sure enough, with just one burger patty in there, I could see how juicy and delicious it would be coming out!

The patties caramelize on both sides, locking in all those juices, there was no need to turn them, a fantastic way to cook homemade burger patties.

If you’re looking for an easy way to cook burger patties, use a sandwich press, you can even toast the buns!

How To Cook A Grilled Cheese Burger In A Sandwich Press

#8 French Toast

Cooking French Toast In A Sandwich Press

Sandwich press French toast, it’s so delicious! I always like to use one or two-day-old brioche or baguette when cooking French toast, whisk castor sugar, cream, and eggs together.

Throw in some fresh vanilla pod if I’ve got it, crank up the sandwich press, brush the plates with melted butter and I’m in business.


  • Soak the bread in the egg wash and place them onto the sandwich press, you don’t need to close the lid you can turn the French toast if you want.

When done sprinkle with some cinnamon sugar, and drizzle over some maple syrup, now that’s an awesome way to cook French Toast! If you are feeling lazy on a Sunday morning cooking French toast using a sandwich press is the way to go!

#9 Bananas

Cooking Bananas In A Sandwich Press

This brings me to bananas, you can’t have French toast without caramelized bananas, it just doesn’t work! When cooking bananas in a pan they tend to become soft and break up, using a sandwich press is better and easier.

Top and tail the bananas, cut lengthways, leave the skin on, sprinkle some brown sugar onto the sandwich press and place the banana cut side down and close it.

Two minutes later you’ve got perfect caramelized bananas, no turning, no risk of them breaking apart and they taste magnificent. More importantly, they complete your French toast breakfast.

#10 Steak

Rare Seared Beef Tenderloin

Can you cook steak in a sandwich press? Some people might say no, I say yes! Cooking steak in a sandwich press, oh yeah! I love cooking a thick-cut piece of tenderloin, rib-eye, or striploin in my sandwich press, the caramelization and flavor are excellent.

Season and oil the steak, place it in the sandwich press and close it down. Depending on how thick the steak is and how long I’ll cook it, 1 or 2-inch thick, I’d leave it for three-four minutes and rest it for two minutes. This should give you med-rare.

If med-rare is not to your taste leave it in the sandwich press for longer, and experiment with the time until you get your preferred doneness.

If you are unsure of the doneness you can always use a digital meat thermometer.

How To Cook Steak In A Sandwich Press

Best Value Sandwich Press

Cuisinart GR-4NP1 5-in-1 Griddler/Sandwich Press

All you need to know about the Cuisinart 5-in-1 griddle!
This multifunctional appliance can cook up any dish.
Whether it is searing Marinated chicken thighs, making perfect juicy burgers, or cooking fish.

Standout Features

  • The Cuisinart 5-in-1 Griddler/Sandwich presses give you the best of all worlds.
  • The floating cover even changes thickness so everything will taste as if it came from your favorite restaurant.
  • Make life easier by incorporating this one device into your daily cooking routine.
  • The possibilities are endless with this wonderful multitasking appliance!

How To Clean A Sandwich Press?

Cooking with a sandwich press with all these different foods it’s bound to get greasy and dirty.

The best way to clean your sandwich press is with absorbent paper towels. Heat it and wipe away any grease or food particles, and wipe down the sides as well.

If you’ve got cheese all over the sandwich press, let it cool down and the cheese will easily come off. If your sandwich press has cast-iron plates rub a little oil on the surface, this will stop it from rusting.

  • If your sandwich press has a non-stick surface, whatever you don’t try and clean it with an abrasive cleaning pad, you’ll scratch the non-stick surface. 

If you’ve got a sandwich press that has removable plates then the job of cleaning becomes much easier, just follow the manufacturer’s instructions.

Final Words

  • Well, there are a lot of foods that you can cook in a sandwich press, these are just some ideas.

It’s a matter of just thinking outside the box when it comes to cooking with a sandwich press.

  • Cooking with a sandwich press is effortless, this old-school kitchen appliance will become the newest cooking tool in your arsenal.
  • I’ve shared with you some awesome ideas on how to make cooking a piece of cake for you.

No worrying about having to clean up pots and pans or using the oven which needs a lot more power than a sandwich press does!

  • Cooking with a sandwich press is a brilliant kitchen tool, especially if you live alone or are living on a budget, or are a student.
  • If you’re reading this and don’t own a sandwich press, I strongly suggest you get one.

I’ve found two that I know would be perfect for cooking the foods that I cook regularly using my sandwich press.

The Blue Diamond Cookware Sizzle Griddle/Sandwich Press and the Cuisinart GR-4NP1 5-in-1 Griddler/Sandwich Press with its removable plates. Cooking with a sandwich press can change your life.

About The Author